kozand

Good people love good people.

No redemption for Irenicus not even an Ascension Irenicus. He is dead he SHOULD be destroyed because he said: TO DIE HERE IS TO CEASE TO EXIST.

No bringing back THE FIVE.

No incest Imoen love, no Sarevok romance. Bhaal is God so what? Would u bed with your sister even if your father's are different?

No good PC loves Valen.

I know I may sound puritan but I am not, I just don't like exegerataions and I do respect people's wish and if they want to make a mod about Valen Romance/Shadow Lord Romance ect. good for them. I just stick with DMG's good role playing suggestions.

I don't like big boss always return, I don't think PC should romance with every rock lying on street.

I don't like forced scenarios. I don't like cheesy weapons, stats, SK and whatnot.

I don't think this is called role playing anymore. It is more like inconsistent wild fantasy. I... don't like uncontrolled fantasies. For me it is a futile and vain effort.

That said I leave u to your thoughts. Because there is freedom of ideas and freedom of will.

PS: I enjoy Ascension or Redemption. Good mods and congrats for creators. But in MY official version no raise BOSS again happens.

PS2: It is a protest. Heck people protest war, war happens. Nobodoy force me to play every mod but I voice my opinion too. I love fantasy not fables.

Just for indulging u: I agree.

Yes Quitch has an independent mind and she trusts herself and this is her work. So why I am bothering her or myself anyway? When she knows what to do already?

Good luck Quitch!

Be well!

I didn't understand what u said Quitch.

But as a general statement not aiming u in particular I think we should not impose on players some not so popular life styles in form of mods. As long as majority won't like it and in this case, no, majority would not like it. I mean a les Imoen. But Imoen romance as a whole is already there and a good mod. No need for replicate it.

Thank u for answering. Alas we have very different views of Imoen. I cannot help u there.

I agree with a)

c) No I meant Imoen as a whole BG1 > BG2 > TOB > TOB epilogue. She is not a leader in start of BG 2, she is a lonely wolf but she will be head of a big thieves guild (TOB) epilogue. She is a manipulator. Imoen Romance mod interpratation is closer to mine.

blackmail: well I don't think she is THAT innocent. She is more like a kender and mischievious halfling in my eyes. And blackmail... well she did not threaten to kill or ruin life of anybody. Taken by sudden impulse she scared Tethtoril a bit that's all. technically blackmail -lexicon- but more like an innocent joke!

rogue vs thief. we are talking about the same thing but we understand different things when we say thief. For me thief is burglar and thug and evil. Rogue is somewhat random, noble and Imoen like. I take it as a PC class. And Imoen becomes a guild leader in future and her origins should be mentioned in BG2 to make her char development realistic. Otherwise I agree with your analysis.

I strongly disagree, although Imoen seems random she does know a lot about lore stuff and Bhaal. Identifying and all. She had used to read. And she is not a sorcerer, but mage. Magecraft requires careful and regular study. I think she reads and reads much but her style is free. She does not like lessons but doing her own research. But she mentions Candlekeep books always. She talks much about Bhaal lore even when PC is ignorant.

Well u can do nothing about it. Yes, big fat man. Just begin BG2 anew read her first dialogue while talking to PC for the first time. Though I agree, it seems weird. Maybe she learned hiding in order to avoid Winthrop and his chores?

As for boys... Let's say my Imoen is not SO naive but she is appearing naive. But her Sarevok months and BG2 tortures changed her deeply. Realy a childish character does not mean a totally indifferent, just living for fun, low wisdom and irresponsible character. I don't think such naive NPCs can help PC. Minsc? Nah! He maybe crazy but not fool! He knows to travel land and survive alone!

Nonono! She did read those sex tomes Quitch! She tells this Anomen in TOB! No naive person would do that and certainly nobody would remained naive after that unless she was mentally retarded.

I understand your point and u think I cannot catch the essence of Imoen. I think your Imoen did not catch the essence of Imoen instead. Nothing to discuss here I am afraid. But maybe I can give u some other ideas to be accepted in future.

Take care.