85 replies to this topic

[Anonymous2]

Forgive me for my late response, my old hardrive crashed, really bad and now i've got a new one.....

I don't agree with this last guys estimate of Ragnos totally dominating Palpatine....i mean come on Palpatine or Darth Sidious was one hell of a Sith Lord, while i agree that Ragnos would eventually win remember Sidious struck down Windu, Fisto, and that other council member(forget his name), his unorthodox almost sluggish lightsaber technique was odd but I certainly believe that he could put up a hell of a fight against Ragnos....and don't forget Sidious took out Yoda too and he was one of the top force users of all time....

On a sidenote i think that Sidious entire demeaner was to me one of a kind, it'll be tough to top the truly greatest badguy in star wars history(vader aside) if they intend on making more movies....his voice, stance, look, inspire such fear....

Star Wars moment i'll never forget....

"Lord Vader"

"Yes Master"

"Rise....."

[Archmage Silver]

Remember that he only took Mace Windu down because Anakin caused a distraction. And as for him being the biggest badass in SW history, yes, I do agree, but that's because he was one of the first two villains invented and people tend to remember the original films pretty good.

[Anonymous2]

Here's one that could of been really possible in the movies....


Darth Vader(Dark Anakin) vs. General Grievous




This might of actually happened had Obi-Wan not killed Grievous....Grievous was supposed to protect the Separatists council and as we all saw in Episode III Vader killed them all, but had Grievous survived his altercation with Kenobi he would of probly made his way back to Mustafar to protect the council....quite a thought Greivous fighting Vader, what a battle that would of been....in the end i'm sure a Dark Anakin Skywalker would of found a way to destroy Grievous, throwing him into the lava pit or something along those lines.....

[Archmage Silver]

I don't think Grievous was a Sith or a Jedi in the traditional sense, but as for him being a force user, yes, even though his ability wasn't that great and his mechanical body was the only thing that made him so dangerous [Read: He wielded 4 lightsabers].

[Sephiroth]

I don't think Grievous was a Sith or a Jedi in the traditional sense, but as for him being a force user, yes, even though his ability wasn't that great and his mechanical body was the only thing that made him so dangerous [Read: He wielded 4 lightsabers].

He had no force potential whatsoever. The reason he wielded 4 lightsabers, he had 4 mechanical arms. Think of him as an early version of Vader, yet still not as cool as Malak (the ultimate Vader wannabe)

I'm also positive Vader (pre-suit) would have killed Grevious. Grevious = learned from Dooku (yet obviously not as good as no force) Anakin = killed Dooku (and Obi-Wan and Palpatine, but much later on)

[Kellen]

I don't think he can be said to have killed either. Obi let himself fall, and Palpy wasn't fighting him.